Robert Bathurst says Dad's Army film was 'creatively bankrupt'
6 years ago
22 August 2019 - 4:00 PM

Robert Bathurst says Dad's Army film was 'creatively bankrupt'

Share on
Share on Facebook
Facebook
X
Share on E-mail
E-mail

\'Cold Feet\' star Robert Bathurst has branded the \'Dad\'s Army\' movie "creatively bankrupt" because it wasn\'t written by the sitcom\'s creators David Croft and Jimmy Perry.

The 62-year-old actor has taken on the role of Sergeant Wilson - originally played by John Le Mesurier in the beloved BBC comedy series which ran from 1968 to 1977 - in the three recreations of lost \'Dad\'s Army\' episodes for TV channel Gold.

Whereas he believes these three remakes have value because they are completing the set of stories penned by the show\'s creators Croft and Perry, Robert insists the 2016 film - which starred Catherine Zeta-Jones and Toby Jones amongst a stellar cast - flopped because it was pastiche.

Dad's Army stage revival thrown into doubt by coronavirus

In an interview on the Series Linked podcast, Robert said: "There\'s been previous outings not written by Croft and Perry. I thought they were sort of creatively bankrupt."

Robert admits he "wrestled" with the idea of playing Sergeant Wilson because the remakes are "fraught with danger" and may not be well-received by fans of the World War II sitcom which starred Arthur Lowe as Captain George Mainwaring in charge of the Home Guard.

However, he ultimately decided to accept the role because the producers were going to stay completely faithful to Croft and Perry\'s original scripts and by making the trio of episodes it meant that the series would finally be complete following the loss of \'The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Walker\', \'A Stripe for Frazer\' and \'Under Fire\' from the BBC archive.

Robert Bathurst slams inaudible actors

Robert - who is most famous for portraying David Marsden in ITV drama \'Cold Feet\' - said: "It\'s fraught with potential dangers because, I mean, who wants to see other people do \'Dad\'s Army\', apart from Arnold Ridley, and Arthur Lowe, and John Le Mesurier, and everybody like that? I wrestled with it, until I realised that it was all about the lost episodes. Those three have never been discovered, and here we are now having remade those and so \'Dad\'s Army\' fans can see all 80 shows, all 80 scripts, but not all with the same people, sadly."

The \'Dad\'s Army\' remakes boast a cast made up of a host of major names with Kevin McNally portraying Captain Mainwaring, Bernard Cribbins as Private Godfrey, Kevin Eldon as Lance Corporal Jones, Mathew Horne as Private Walker, David Hayman as Private Frazer and Tom Rosenthal as Pike and they will air from Sunday August 25 on Gold.

Share on
Share on Facebook
Facebook
X
Share on E-mail
E-mail

You might like these
Dad's Army stage revival thrown into doubt by coronavirus

Dad's Army stage revival thrown into doubt by coronavirus

2 June 2020 - 2:00 PM

Dad's Army stage revival thrown into doubt by coronavirus
Robert Bathurst slams inaudible actors

Robert Bathurst slams inaudible actors

30 May 2020 - 1:00 PM

Robert Bathurst slams inaudible actors
Plebs to end after five seasons

Plebs to end after five seasons

30 April 2020 - 12:00 PM

Plebs to end after five seasons
John Thomson: Cold Feet is not cancelled

John Thomson: Cold Feet is not cancelled

28 February 2020 - 5:00 PM

John Thomson: Cold Feet is not cancelled
ITV confirm Cold Feet break but show will return 'at a later date'

ITV confirm Cold Feet break but show will return 'at a later date'

17 February 2020 - 1:00 PM

ITV confirm Cold Feet break but show will return 'at a later date'

Louis Tomlinson Reflects on One Direction’s "What Makes You Beautiful"
19 March 2026

Louis Tomlinson Reflects on One Direction’s "What Makes You Beautiful"

Louis Tomlinson Reflects on One Direction’s "What Makes You Beautiful"
Dianne Buswell and Joe Sugg Welcome Baby Boy Bowden
19 March 2026

Dianne Buswell and Joe Sugg Welcome Baby Boy Bowden

Dianne Buswell and Joe Sugg Welcome Baby Boy Bowden
Dua Lipa Joins George Clooney for New Nespresso Campaign
19 March 2026

Dua Lipa Joins George Clooney for New Nespresso Campaign

Dua Lipa Joins George Clooney for New Nespresso Campaign
Carol Vorderman Discusses Her "Special Friends" and Approach to Relationships
18 March 2026

Carol Vorderman Discusses Her "Special Friends" and Approach to Relationships

Carol Vorderman Discusses Her "Special Friends" and Approach to Relationships
Alice Evans Faces Personal Loss Following Court Ruling
18 March 2026

Alice Evans Faces Personal Loss Following Court Ruling

Alice Evans Faces Personal Loss Following Court Ruling
Geordie Shore Series Finale Removed from Streaming After Editing Blunder
18 March 2026

Geordie Shore Series Finale Removed from Streaming After Editing Blunder

Geordie Shore Series Finale Removed from Streaming After Editing Blunder
Harry Hill Recalls Overhearing Blunt Feedback from Keeley Hawes
17 March 2026

Harry Hill Recalls Overhearing Blunt Feedback from Keeley Hawes

Harry Hill Recalls Overhearing Blunt Feedback from Keeley Hawes
Paddy McGuinness Unveils Physical Transformation for Men's Health Cover
17 March 2026

Paddy McGuinness Unveils Physical Transformation for Men's Health Cover

Paddy McGuinness Unveils Physical Transformation for Men's Health Cover
Barry Keoghan Dismisses James Bond Casting Rumors
17 March 2026

Barry Keoghan Dismisses James Bond Casting Rumors

Barry Keoghan Dismisses James Bond Casting Rumors
Russ Cook Announces He Will Become a Father
15 March 2026

Russ Cook Announces He Will Become a Father

Russ Cook Announces He Will Become a Father
Louise Thompson Shares Update on Campaign for Maternity Commissioner
15 March 2026

Louise Thompson Shares Update on Campaign for Maternity Commissioner

Louise Thompson Shares Update on Campaign for Maternity Commissioner
Rita Simons Shares Health Update Before Upcoming Surgeries
15 March 2026

Rita Simons Shares Health Update Before Upcoming Surgeries

Rita Simons Shares Health Update Before Upcoming Surgeries
Statistic Statistic